When managing gestational diabetes, it’s essential to be mindful of everything you consume, including your coffee. While coffee itself is typically safe during pregnancy, the type of coffee creamer you choose can make a significant impact on your blood sugar levels. Many commercial creamers are loaded with sugars, unhealthy fats, and artificial ingredients that can cause blood sugar spikes. However, there are plenty of safe, low-carb, and delicious options to keep your coffee enjoyable and blood sugar-friendly!
Let's explore the best coffee creamer options for women with gestational diabetes, so you can continue savoring your coffee!
Gestational diabetes occurs when your body struggles to regulate blood sugar levels during pregnancy. This can be due to insufficient insulin production or the body’s inability to efficiently use insulin. Since foods and drinks, especially those high in sugar and refined carbs, can cause blood sugar spikes, it’s crucial to select options that help stabilize your glucose levels and manage blood sugar control during pregnancy.
Many store-bought coffee creamers, particularly flavored or pre-sweetened varieties, contain refined sugars, hydrogenated oils (trans fats), and artificial additives. These ingredients can quickly elevate your blood sugar levels and make managing your condition more challenging. There are various best coffee creamer options available that can help manage blood sugar levels effectively. By choosing healthier alternatives, you can enjoy your morning coffee without putting your blood sugar at risk.
What It Is: A popular dairy-free option with a mild, nutty flavor, unsweetened almond milk is low in carbs and typically free from added sugars.
Why It’s Good for You:
Low in carbohydrates and calories
Contains healthy fats and protein
Rich in vitamin E
No added sugars, so it won’t spike your blood sugar
How to Use It: Pour a small amount of unsweetened almond milk into your coffee. For extra flavor, add a dash of cinnamon or vanilla extract—without the sugar!
What It Is: This dairy-free milk alternative offers a creamy texture with a mild coconut flavor, and like almond milk, it has minimal carbs and no added sugars.
Why It’s Good for You:
Low in carbs
Contains healthy fats from coconut
No added sugars, making it blood-sugar-friendly
How to Use It: Use it as a 1:1 replacement for regular creamers. For a creamier cup, opt for coconut cream, or add cinnamon or stevia for sweetness without the sugar.
What It Is: Heavy cream is a high-fat dairy product that can add richness to your coffee without any added sugars.
Why It’s Good for You:
High in healthy fats, which can help stabilize blood sugar levels
No added sugars
Very low in carbs, making it ideal for gestational diabetes
Using a sugar-free version further reduces carb intake
How to Use It: Heavy cream is rich, so use it sparingly—just a tablespoon or two will add enough creaminess to your coffee.
What It Is: A blend of equal parts whole milk and cream, half-and-half is a great option for those who enjoy a creamier coffee without too much fat.
Why It’s Good for You:
Lower in carbs than flavored creamers or sugary alternatives
Contains both fat and protein to help manage blood sugar
Best used in moderation, as it’s not as low in carbs as almond or coconut milk
How to Use It: Add a small amount to your coffee to achieve a creamy texture.
What It Is: Protein-enriched milk (such as Fairlife milk) is a dairy option that contains more protein than regular milk. It’s a great way to boost your protein intake while enjoying a creamy coffee.
Why It’s Good for You:
Higher in protein, which can help stabilize blood sugar and keep you fuller for longer
Low in carbs, especially when choosing options like Fairlife
No added sugars (if choosing the unsweetened version)
How to Use It: Add it to your coffee for a creamier texture and protein boost. It pairs well with iced coffee or lattes and is perfect if you’re looking for a more filling option.
What It Is: A pre-made, ready-to-drink protein shake, often found in grocery stores, made with high-quality protein sources (like whey or plant-based protein) and typically low in carbs. It’s a convenient option for adding extra protein without having to mix powders.
Why It’s Good for You:
Provides a quick, convenient source of protein, which helps stabilize blood sugar levels and keep you feeling fuller for longer
Usually low in carbs (if you choose sugar-free or low-carb options), making it a great choice for managing blood sugar
Can be a filling option, especially if you’re on the go
How to Use It: Simply grab a bottle and pour it into your coffee for an instant protein boost. It works especially well in iced coffee or lattes and makes for a creamy, satisfying addition to your drink. You can also enjoy it on its own as a snack or breakfast option.
Note: Always check the label for nutritional information
To keep your blood sugar levels stable, here’s a list of ingredients to watch out for in coffee creamers:
Added Sugars: Look out for sugar or corn syrup on the ingredient list. These ingredients can cause blood sugar spikes. Choose sugar-free options to manage your intake.
Hydrogenated Oils (Trans Fats): These unhealthy fats can contribute to inflammation and other health issues. Avoid creamers that list these oils.
Artificial Sweeteners: Ingredients like aspartame or sucralose can have unpredictable effects on your blood sugar. Opt for natural sweeteners like stevia or monk fruit.
Flavored Creamers: Pre-flavored creamers are often loaded with sugars and artificial ingredients. Stick with unsweetened varieties to avoid unnecessary additives.
Sugar Alcohols: While used in low-sugar and sugar-free products, sugar alcohols can cause digestive issues like gas and bloating. Consider alternatives that avoid these problems.
Here are a few specific coffee creamers to consider:
Silk Unsweetened Almond Milk: No added sweeteners
Why It’s Great: Low in carbs, free from added sugars, and rich in vitamin E.
Califia Farms Unsweetened Almond Milk Coffee Creamer: No added sweeteners
Why It’s Great: Smooth and creamy with no added sugars.
Nutpods Dairy-Free Creamer (Unsweetened): No added sweeteners
Why It’s Great: Blends coconut cream and almond milk for a creamy texture with no added sugars, various flavors.
Heavy Cream (Organic Valley or Horizon): No added sweeteners
Why It’s Great: Low in carbs, rich in healthy fats, and perfect for those who prefer a richer coffee.
So Delicious Dairy-Free Coconut Milk Creamer (Unsweetened): No added sweeteners
Why It’s Great: A dairy-free option that’s low in carbs and provides a subtle coconut flavor.
Half-and-Half (Organic Valley or Horizon): No added sweeteners
Why It’s Great: A good balance of creaminess and protein, great in moderation.
Chobani Zero Sugar Coffee Creamer: Stevia extract
Why It’s Great: Low in carbs, sweet cream and salted caramel flavor.
Chobani Regular Coffee Creamer: Cane sugar (natural sugar)
Why It’s Great: Offers a balanced sweetness for those who prefer a more traditional creamer, various flavors.
If you love a little sweetness in your coffee but need to count carbs—you’ve got options! Natural sweeteners like Stevia (e.g., SweetLeaf, Truvia) and monk fruit (e.g., Lakanto, Pure Monk) are great choices. Erythritol-based sweeteners (like Swerve) can also be a good fit, but some people find sugar alcohols cause mild digestive discomfort.
When it comes to flavored syrups, go for sugar-free options like Jordan’s Skinny Syrups or Torani Sugar-Free Syrups, which use sucralose or allulose instead of sugar. If you prefer a more natural route, consider a splash of unsweetened vanilla almond milk or cinnamon for added flavor without the carbs. Always check labels—some "sugar-free" products still contain ingredients that can impact blood sugar.
If you’re craving your usual coffee shop favorite, here are some smart swaps and customizations to keep your blood sugar in check while still enjoying a delicious drink!
Americano with unsweetened almond or coconut milk + splash of heavy cream
Iced espresso with almond milk + splash of half & half
Espresso mixed with a vanilla protein shake (Fairlife, Premier Protein, etc.)
Cold brew with unsweetened almond or coconut milk + sugar-free vanilla syrup
Espresso over ice + frothed unsweetened milk of choice
Cold brew + splash of heavy cream + sugar-free caramel syrup
Americano with a splash of half & half + sugar-free caramel flavoring
Iced espresso with a caramel protein shake (blended for extra creaminess!)
Hot coffee with a splash of Fairlife caramel protein shake
Cold brew + splash of heavy cream + sugar-free chocolate syrup
Espresso blended with unsweetened cocoa powder + almond milk + sweetener of choice
Hot coffee with Fairlife chocolate protein shake for a creamy, high-protein mocha
Iced espresso + frothed almond or coconut milk + sugar-free chocolate syrup
Iced coffee with unsweetened coconut milk + sugar-free vanilla syrup
Cold brew with coconut Fairlife protein shake for a creamy, high-protein version
Espresso with heavy cream and a sprinkle of unsweetened shredded coconut
Blended coffee with ice, coconut milk, and a touch of cinnamon
Cold brew + unsweetened almond milk + sugar-free vanilla syrup
Americano with a splash of heavy cream + sugar-free vanilla flavoring
Iced espresso with a vanilla protein shake
Homemade: Espresso + frothed almond milk + vanilla extract
Cold brew + whipped heavy cream + sugar-free sweetener
Iced americano + half & half + sugar-free vanilla syrup
Blended espresso + Fairlife vanilla protein shake for a frothy, creamy drink
Whipped coffee (Dalgona style) with a sugar-free sweetener + unsweetened almond milk
Iced coffee + unsweetened almond milk + pumpkin spice seasoning + sugar-free vanilla syrup
Espresso + splash of heavy cream + a dash of cinnamon & nutmeg
Cold brew with pumpkin-flavored protein shake (Premier Protein has a seasonal one!)
Brewed coffee + unsweetened almond milk + pumpkin puree + pumpkin spice
Order: Iced Americano with unsweetened almond + splash of heavy cream for creaminess
Alternative: Espresso over ice with a sugar-free vanilla flavor shot or iced espresso with a vanilla protein shake as creamer
Order: Iced Americano with a splash of half & half + 1-2 pumps of sugar-free vanilla syrup + caramel drizzle
Alternative: Iced espresso with caramel protein shake
Order: Iced coffee or Americano with a splash of heavy cream (+ 1 shot of espresso) + 1 pump mocha syrup
Alternative: Iced espresso with unsweetened cocoa powder + almond milk + sugar-free sweetener
Order: Iced coffee with unsweetened almond milk + pumpkin spice seasoning (no pumpkin sauce) + 1-2 pumps sugar-free vanilla
Alternative: Espresso with heavy cream + cinnamon + nutmeg + sugar-free sweetener
Order: Iced Americano with unsweetened almond milk + sugar-free vanilla syrup + splash of heavy cream for creaminess
Alternative: Iced espresso with vanilla protein shake
Order: Iced coffee or cold brew with heavy cream + 1-2 pumps of sugar-free vanilla syrup + 1 pump mocha syrup
Alternative: Iced espresso with a vanilla protein shake + unsweetened cocoa powder
Order: Iced coffee with unsweetened almond milk + splash of heavy cream
Alternative: Espresso over ice with sugar-free vanilla flavor shot + almond milk or iced espresso with a vanilla shake as creamer
Order: Cold brew with unsweetened almond milk + sugar-free caramel flavor shot
Alternative: Iced espresso with half & half + sugar-free caramel flavor shot
Order: Cold brew with a splash of heavy cream + sugar-free mocha flavor shot
Alternative: Iced espresso with unsweetened cocoa powder + almond milk + sugar-free sweetener
Order: Cold brew with sugar-free vanilla flavor shot + splash of heavy cream
Alternative: Iced espresso with a vanilla protein shake
Order: Hot coffee with unsweetened almond milk + sugar-free hazelnut flavor shot
Alternative: Iced coffee with sugar-free hazelnut flavor shot + splash of half & half
Enjoying your coffee while managing gestational diabetes is totally possible with the right choices! The key is opting for low-carb options like unsweetened almond milk, coconut milk, heavy cream, or protein-enriched milk. Always check the labels for hidden sugars, artificial sweeteners, or other additives that could mess with your numbers.
Also, it’s best to enjoy your coffee after you’ve eaten something — not on an empty stomach. Drinking coffee on an empty stomach can cause blood sugar spikes or crashes, and might make you feel jittery or unsettled. Pair your coffee with a balanced meal or snack to keep things stable and feel your best! If you’re ever unsure about what’s best for you, don’t hesitate to chat with your healthcare provider for personalized advice. Enjoy your cup of coffee!
1. Can I drink coffee while pregnant if I have gestational diabetes?
Yes, moderate coffee consumption is generally safe during pregnancy, even for those with gestational diabetes. Just be mindful of how much sugar and creamer you add.
2. What is the best sweetener to use in coffee for gestational diabetes?
Natural sweeteners like stevia or monk fruit are great options. Avoid or limit refined sugars or artificial sweeteners, which can impact blood sugar.
3. How much coffee can I drink with gestational diabetes?
Moderate coffee consumption—around 1-2 cups per day—is generally safe. Excess caffeine can affect blood sugar levels, so it's important to monitor your intake.
4. Can I have flavored creamers for my coffee?
Flavored creamers often contain added sugars that can spike your blood sugar. Stick with unsweetened options, or add natural flavors like vanilla extract or cinnamon.
5. Are sugar substitutes safe for gestational diabetes?
Yes, sugar substitutes like stevia, monk fruit, and erythritol are generally safe for those managing gestational diabetes. These sweeteners have little to no impact on blood sugar levels. However, be cautious with sugar alcohols, as they may cause digestive discomfort for some individuals. Always check the ingredients to ensure you're choosing a safe alternative for your body and consult with your healthcare provider to ensure it aligns with their recommendations.
Get a Free 20-Day Shopping List
